5G Technology World

  • 5G Technology and Engineering
  • FAQs
  • Apps
  • Devices
  • IoT
  • RF
  • Radar
  • Wireless Design
  • Learn
    • 5G Videos
    • Ebooks
    • EE Training Days
    • FAQs
    • Learning Center
    • Tech Toolboxes
    • Webinars/Digital Events
  • Handbooks
    • 2024
    • 2023
    • 2022
    • 2021
  • Resources
    • Design Guide Library
    • EE World Digital Issues
    • Engineering Diversity & Inclusion
    • Engineering Training Days
    • LEAP Awards
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe

Court Scraps $32.2M Judgement Against Sprint in Prism Technologies Lawsuit

By Bevin Fletcher | August 14, 2017

The U.S. District Court in Nebraska last week threw out a $32.2 million judgement against Sprint for infringing on two of Prism Technologies’ network security patents.

The August 8 ruling overturns a March decision by a federal appeals court in Nebraska that upheld a $30 million verdict against Sprint in the patent infringement case.

Prism filed a motion to lift the court’s stay and enforce the $30 million judgement against Sprint, while Sprint moved for relief from the judgement or for a further stay.

The issue at hand were two patents – Nos. 8,127,345 and 8,387,155 – that describe “managing access to protected computer resources.”

Prism has filed similar claims against other carriers alleging infringement on these patents. In June, a Federal Circuit Court ruled Prism’s case against T-Mobile asserted patent claims that “merely recite a host of elements that are indisputably generic computer components and recite patent ineligible subject matter.” Thus, the court found the patent infringement claims invalid.

But in its case against Sprint seeking payment, Prism argued the Federal Court’s finding in the T-Mobile case could not be applied to its lawsuit against Sprint. Specifically, Prism claimed at least two of the patent claims at issue in the Sprint case were not invalidated by the T-Mobile decision. 

Sprint, on the other hand, argued that the carrier should be given relief based on the T-Mobile decision, and cited a July 25 order from the Federal Circuit Court that directed the “the May 2017 mandate does not alter how the district court should decide in the preclusive effect of the T-Mobile ruling…”

The court sided with Sprint, and in a memorandum opinion, U.S. District Court Senior Judge Lyle E. Strom wrote “the patent claims at issue in the T-Mobile case, which were invalidated by the Federal Circuit, were and are the same claims at issue here.”

“Given that the Federal Circuit has conclusively adjudged the patent claims, which provide the very basis for Prism’s $30 million judgement, to be invalid; the Court finds no just reason why such a judgement out to stand when the claims ‘are predicated on a nullity’ and unenforceable to the rest of the world,” he concluded.

Accordingly, since the law already determined Prism’s patent claims didn’t hold up against T-Mobile, the court granted Sprint’s motion for relief from the judgement.

Sprint was represented by Sidley Austin partners Michael J. Bettinger and Irene Yang. Carter Phillips was also part of the team.


Filed Under: Carriers

 

Next Article

← Previous Article
Next Article →

Related Articles Read More >

eSIM
eSIM eases changing carriers for phones and IoT
QoE and QoS comparison
Benchmarking in 5G: More important than ever
iPhone 12
I bought a 5G phone, now what?
6G
Key takeaways from 6G Symposium

Featured Contributions

  • Overcome Open RAN test and certification challenges
  • Wireless engineers need AI to build networks
  • Why AI chips need PCIe 7.0 IP interconnects
  • circuit board timing How timing and synchronization improve 5G spectrum efficiency
  • Wi-Fi 7 and 5G for FWA need testing
More Featured Contributions

EE TECH TOOLBOX

“ee
Tech Toolbox: 5G Technology
This Tech Toolbox covers the basics of 5G technology plus a story about how engineers designed and built a prototype DSL router mostly from old cellphone parts. Download this first 5G/wired/wireless communications Tech Toolbox to learn more!

EE LEARNING CENTER

EE Learning Center
“5g
EXPAND YOUR KNOWLEDGE AND STAY CONNECTED
Get the latest info on technologies, tools and strategies for EE professionals.

Engineering Training Days

engineering
“bills
5G Technology World
  • Enews Signup
  • EE World Online
  • DesignFast
  • EDABoard Forums
  • Electro-Tech-Online Forums
  • Microcontroller Tips
  • Analogic Tips
  • Connector Tips
  • Engineer’s Garage
  • EV Engineering
  • Power Electronic Tips
  • Sensor Tips
  • Test and Measurement Tips
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise

Copyright © 2025 WTWH Media LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media
Privacy Policy

Search 5G Technology World